Quick Access
Quick Comparison: SKC NoiseCHEK vs. TSI Edge 5
| Feature | SKC NoiseCHEK | TSI Edge 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Battery Life | 40+ hours | 40+ hours |
| Study Duration Supported | Full 24-hr study or ~2 days monitoring | Full 24-hr study or ~2 days monitoring |
| Virtual Dosimeters | 4 | 3 |
| Octave Band Analysis (1/1 & 1/3) | ✓ | ✕ |
| Mobile App | ✓ | ✕ |
| Software Platform | DataTrac | DMS (Detection Management Software) |
| Intrinsically Safe | ✓ | ✓ |
| Primary Use Case | Advanced analysis & mobile review | Straightforward compliance logging & MSHA |
Similarities Between the SKC NoiseCHEK and TSI Edge 5
For field endurance, both units are top-tier performers:
- Both offer 40+ hours of battery life 00:20
- That capacity allows for a full 24-hour study or nearly two consecutive days of monitoring on a single charge 00:27
- Both units are intrinsically safe, making them suitable for hazardous environments 01:53
Battery Life and Power
When it comes to field endurance, both units are top-tier performers:
- Run Time: Both the SKC and the Edge 5 offer 40+ hours of battery life 00:20
- Study Duration: This capacity allows for a full 24-hour study or nearly two consecutive days of monitoring on a single charge 00:27
Software Ecosystems
Each device operates within its own dedicated software environment for data extraction and analysis:
- SKC NoiseCHEK: Uses DataTrac software to manage and download all noise study files 00:36
- TSI Edge 5: Requires DMS (Detection Management Software) 00:44
Pro Tip: The DMS software is highly versatile if you use other Quest equipment, as it's also compatible with the SoundPro, Sound Examiner, and QuestTemp units 00:52.
Functionality and Advanced Features
The primary differences lie in the depth of data analysis and hardware sensitivity:
SKC NoiseCHEK (Advanced Analysis)
- Features 4 virtual dosimeters 01:00
- Supports 1/1 and 1/3 octave bands for detailed frequency analysis 01:00
- Includes a mobile app for viewing data and reviewing history directly on the device without needing a PC 01:09
TSI Edge 5 (Standard Compliance)
- Features 3 virtual dosimeters 01:25
- While it lacks octave band capabilities, its microphone is notably more intuitive and sensitive than the SKC's 01:33
- Data lookup in the DMS software is often considered easier for viewing a wide range of data files simultaneously 01:40
Summary: Which Is Right for You?
Both units are intrinsically safe 01:53, making them suitable for hazardous environments. Your choice should depend on your reporting requirements:
Choose the SKC NoiseCHEK if:
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes. Both units are intrinsically safe, making them suitable for use in hazardous environments.
The SKC NoiseCHEK, with 4 virtual dosimeters and support for 1/1 and 1/3 octave band analysis, plus a mobile app for on-device data review.
No. The Edge 5 doesn't support octave bands, though its microphone is considered more intuitive and sensitive than the SKC's.
The NoiseCHEK uses DataTrac. The Edge 5 uses DMS (Detection Management Software), which is also compatible with other Quest instruments like the SoundPro, Sound Examiner, and QuestTemp.
Both offer 40+ hours of battery life — enough for a full 24-hour study or nearly two consecutive days of monitoring on a single charge.
Yes. The SKC NoiseCHEK is highly sensitive to walkie-talkies and Bluetooth interference, so keep it clear of those devices during monitoring.
